A video now going viral reveals a 14-month-old being thrown into the pool as a part of a “shock float take a look at”, leaving commenters in splits.
The video was posted to TikTok on March 11 by the infant’s mother, Simone Christensen, who wrote: “I do know it sounds scary, however due to these lessons she will save herself in an emergency!” The submit has garnered over 52 million views and over 4 million likes.
It additionally obtained almost 62,000 feedback from viewers who couldn’t agree on whether or not infants must be subjected to the float take a look at.
The textual content overlay of the video learn, “Watch my 14 month outdated child go her shock float take a look at.”
Within the video, an grownup takes Christensen’s daughter, who’s totally dressed, and throws her right into a pool. Nonetheless, the infant lady has been left to handle herself, though she has been taken care of.
Inside a couple of seconds, the infant raises its head above the water, however by accident slips backwards and will get caught the wrong way up. Lastly, the infant floats on the floor of the water on its again.
A few of Christensen’s commentators criticized the float take a look at, calling it “incorrect”.
“Improper incorrect incorrect on so many ranges,” wrote lyndsey.jt.
“Brother preventing in your life, that is no lesson,” mentioned Franco Dita.
“In no way,” remarked Jade Blanchard.
“She’s a child lady for God’s sake. HOW-TO [you] Count on him to know h**l what is going on on and what to do or perceive?” Rachel requested.
In response to the response, Christensen reported that her daughter had accomplished 5 months of swimming previous to the take a look at.
She wrote within the remark part of the submit, “After 5 months of regular classes you actually cannot discover the half the place it is a one-time take a look at.”
In keeping with the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), “[a]Ought to mother and father and youngsters 1 yr outdated be taught to swim?”
“Your youngster ought to be taught primary swimming abilities: to enter the water, come to the floor, spin, stroll no less than 25 yards by means of the water and be capable to get out of the water,” the AAP mentioned. Though swimming classes won’t make any youngster a “drowning keeper,” they will add “a layer of security” for kids, together with those that are at excessive danger of drowning.
In relation to shock float checks, nevertheless, pediatrician and AAP fellow Dr. Andrew J. Bernstein mentioned he does not assume these checks are “protected or applicable” for kids.
,[T]There’s a vital danger right here [of] Water goes into the lungs if a baby does not maintain their breath for a very long time or on the proper time,” explains Bernstein. Father. “This could result in a scarcity of oxygen to the mind, pneumonia, or loss of life.”
in a press release to newsweekDr Linda Kwan, member of the AAP Council on Damage, Violence and Poison Prevention, mentioned: “The AAP’s pointers have all the time been based mostly on ‘do no hurt’; there are lots of examples of interventions within the historical past of damage prevention that had been worse moderately than ineffective. , they’d surprising unhealthy results.
“The toddler survival swimming talent that this 14-month-old demonstrated requires 5 months of classes, which often embody a number of periods per week with every session involving the toddler repeatedly dipping Being submerged and unable to breathe is finally a distressing, life-threatening occasion at any age. As well as, many crucial, recurrent episodes of no assist from adults add further trauma. Psychological long-term trauma is an actual entity in infants and younger kids,” Kwan continued.
However, some commentators appreciated the float take a look at.
“Nice class for youths it might probably save [their lives],” Nomore mentioned.
“Nice job mother or father. If she collapses once you’re not there, she’ll know what to do,” wrote Vetteygirl00.
How_bri_sees, a self-proclaimed ER nurse, mentioned: “[T]He might have saved so many kids. Get them began early.”
newsweek Christensen reached out for remark, however didn’t hear again in time for publication.
Christensen is not the primary mother to go viral for her divisive parenting choice. In November, a mom sparked an internet debate after sharing that her 10-year-old daughter had by no means been to high school. Additionally in November, it went viral on TikTok after a mom shared that her child’s bedtime was midnight. And in 2019, an argument erupted within the feedback part of a video that confirmed a teen in a busy Florida intersection signing my signal, “I lied.”
Up to date 04/05/2022, 11:42PM ET: This story has been up to date with feedback from Dr. Linda Kwan.